I finally came across MixBook. Here you can start from a blank card and you can order an exact amount if you want, not just a rounded number of cards. You can pick from 3 premium choices of cardstock and in too many colors to name. It took us about 3 hours to finish our card, we had to find out what we wanted first lol. But we finally finished it, 100% on our own --- BIG SMILES ---
This is just a screen grab since we won't be getting them in the mail till a couple weeks.